The Benner cycle (1875): beautiful chart, untestable
Failure type: none. Verdict: untestable with what we have.
The idea
Samuel Benner's 1875 chart marks years of panic, good times and hard times on a repeating schedule that is often shown extended to the present.
What we found
- Its turning points sit on whole calendar years. With roughly 21 years of daily ETF data, the chart makes only a handful of calls we could check, which is no basis for statistics.
- Eyeballing: it has "good times" peaking in 1999 and 2007, and a crash year in 2019 that is a year off from the 2020 crash. It had hard times for 2012 and good times for 2016, and both were ordinary years in a long rally.
Why it's here
It's a curiosity. We do not claim it failed a test, only that it can't be tested here. We would rather say that than make up a p-value.
Research and education only. These are paper results from historical data on a limited set of funds. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a prediction. See Legal.