Wait for the stars to align: 24 setups, 0 survivors

· 1 min read

Failure type: overfit. Verdict: nothing promoted. Validation years never opened.

The idea

Instead of always being invested, wait for a "confluence" of two or three conditions, hold a fixed 1, 3 or 6 months, and sit in T-bills otherwise.

What we did

  • 8 setups defined from indicators we already had (for example: a deep pullback in an ETF still in a long-term uptrend, entered once momentum turns back up; a volatility spike that calms; a breakout after a quiet stretch). 3 horizons (21, 63 and 126 sessions). 24 tests.
  • Rule written first: at least 30 events on 15 unique dates; beat random entry dates in the same ETF; a bootstrap confidence interval entirely above zero; false-discovery rate q ≤ 0.10 across all 24.

What happened

0 of 24 survived. The closest:

Setup Horizon Extra return vs random dates Events FDR q
Deep pullback in an uptrend, momentum turning up 6 months +5.9% 55 (43 dates) 0.16
Calming volatility 1 month +1.3% 484 0.16
Same pullback setup 3 months +3.5% 58 0.16

Setups that fired often were indistinguishable from random entries in the same ETF. One setup never had 30 events at any horizon.

We also report eight 63-day portfolio books for context. The best Sharpe (0.57, against SPY's 0.41) belonged to a setup that was 83% invested with about no event edge, which is just market exposure.

Why it failed

With 24 tries on 23 ETFs, +5.9% on 55 events does not stand out from luck. We did not loosen the q ≤ 0.10 bar after seeing 0.16.

Receipts: the setups were written down and committed before any returns were computed. 24 event trials plus 8 reporting-only books.

Research and education only. These are paper results from historical data on a limited set of funds. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a prediction. See Legal.